What to look for when reviewing conflicts of interest in advice
Anyone who gives financial advice faces situations where their own interests, or those of their firm, could influence the guidance they offer. A conflict of interest does not always mean bad advice. But when a conflict exists and remains undisclosed, it can erode the trust that the client places in the adviser. Recognising where conflicts arise is the first step toward managing them honestly.
For advisers who work within a product neutral planning model, these checks become especially important. A practice built on independence can only maintain that stance if every recommendation is tested against the same question: does this choice serve the client first, or does it serve someone else’s bottom line?
Check your compensation structure
The most common source of conflict is how the adviser gets paid. Commission-based arrangements, volume bonuses, or tiered payouts from product providers create an incentive to recommend one product over another, even when the difference in suitability is small. Ask yourself whether the compensation you receive could reasonably be seen as influencing the recommendation. If the answer is yes, you have a conflict that needs to be disclosed and managed. Even in fee-only models, conflicts can appear. A flat annual retainer might make it tempting to avoid time-consuming work, while an hourly rate could encourage inefficiency. The key is to examine every revenue stream for its potential to pull the advice away from the client’s best interest.
Beyond your own income, look at the firm’s revenue model. Does the practice receive any soft-dollar benefits, such as paid-for conference trips, research access, or marketing support from product manufacturers? These arrangements can create a subtle bias that is hard to spot but equally corrosive. Transparency means being willing to name every source of revenue, no matter how small.
Review the scope of products and providers you consider
A narrow product shelf is a red flag. If you only ever recommend products from one or two providers, the reason should be documented and defensible, not simply a matter of convenience. True independent financial planning requires that you survey the whole market and select the most suitable option, not just the one that is easiest to access. Ask yourself whether you have a formal process for scanning the market or whether you rely on habit and familiarity. A checklist for market review should include checking for newer entrants, lower-cost alternatives, and products designed for the specific client circumstance in front of you. If you skip this step, you risk missing a better fit. That gap is a conflict, because your comfort with a familiar product has crowded out the client’s interest in a better one.
It is also worth checking whether your firm has any ownership ties to product manufacturers. A firm that owns a stake in a fund manager or an insurance company faces an inherent conflict. Even if the adviser on the ground does not feel that pressure, the structure itself creates a bias that must be acknowledged. Clients deserve to know about these relationships so they can weigh the advice accordingly.
Examine your referral and partnership networks
Conflicts do not only come from product providers. Referral arrangements with accountants, lawyers, or mortgage brokers can steer clients toward particular solutions. If you receive a fee or a reciprocal referral from a professional partner, that arrangement can colour the advice you give. Your client might be better served by a different specialist, but your network nudges you toward the person who sends business your way. To guard against this, keep a written record of all referral arrangements and review them annually. Ask whether the referral relationship is disclosed to the client before the introduction is made. The same principle applies to any partnership where money or favours change hands.
Even informal relationships can create conflicts. A long friendship with a particular product provider’s representative can unconsciously tilt your recommendations. The remedy is the same: document the relationship and disclose it when relevant. The more you normalise disclosure, the less awkward it becomes.
Check your personal biases and assumptions
Not every conflict is financial. Personal beliefs about certain investment strategies, asset classes, or insurance types can lead you to dismiss valid alternatives without proper analysis. A planner who strongly believes that property is always a better investment than shares may overlook a client’s need for liquidity or diversification. Independent financial planning demands that you set aside personal preference and evaluate each option on its merits for that specific client. One way to catch this is to ask yourself whether you would recommend the same solution if the client were a close friend or a family member. If your answer changes depending on who the client is, you have uncovered a bias worth examining.
A related check is whether you have sought a second opinion on your more complex cases. Reviewing your work with a peer who operates under a different model can reveal blind spots you did not know you had. If you never test your reasoning against someone else’s, you may be too confident in your own assumptions.
Assess your disclosure practices
Disclosure is the most visible sign of a healthy conflict management process. But disclosure is not just a form to sign. It should happen early, in plain language, and cover every material conflict you have identified. Ask yourself whether your client understands the nature of the conflict, not just that one exists. For example, saying “we receive a commission from this fund” is different from explaining how that commission compares to what other funds pay and what that difference might mean for the client’s returns over time. Effective disclosure helps the client make an informed decision about whether to follow your advice despite the conflict. If your disclosure feels like a legal disclaimer, it probably is not serving its purpose. Rewrite it until it reads like a straightforward conversation.
Finally, review your ongoing monitoring process. A conflict that was manageable at the start of a relationship can grow over time. A product that was suitable three years ago may no longer be the best option, but your ongoing trail commission creates a disincentive to move the client. Regular reviews of the client’s portfolio, conducted with the same product-neutral lens you used at the outset, catch these drift issues. Document every review, and be prepared to recommend a change even when it reduces your income. That willingness is what separates a genuine advice practice from a sales operation dressed up as planning.
Working through these checks regularly is not a one-off exercise. The financial services landscape shifts, new products appear, and your own circumstances evolve. A structured checklist helps you stay honest, but the real work is in the habit of asking the uncomfortable questions. When you can answer each one clearly and in writing, you know you are serving your clients as they deserve to be served.
Ends · THEFIDUCIARYDESK